Archive for May 29th, 2009

Sunderland end of term reports (4): seven good, seven bad

Friday, May 29th, 2009

Petesix

Since Salut! Sunderland burst into action in Jan 2007, Pete Sixsmith has delivered a seven-word verdict – known collectively as Sixer’s Sevens – on each match, in relatively few cases games not actually attended by him. Looked at over a season, these judgements reveal a mixture of hope and despondency, wit and wisdom. In the concluding chapter of our book of end-of-term reports, Pete maintains the theme of seven for a sharp appraisal of a second successive – and ultimately successful, if that’s the correct word – relegation dogfight. Salut! Sunderland is open to other Sunderland fans who may wish to reopen the series; they should offer their own end-of-term reports using the e-mail link (above left) …

An interesting and eventful season for those of the red and white striped persuasion.

As seven is my keynote number, it seemed an idea – good or not is a matter for you, the readers, to decide – to look at seven highlights and seven low points of 2008-2009. No prizes for guessing which of the two took the longest to think of.

(more…)

Sunderland end of term reports (3):

Friday, May 29th, 2009

Danny


Week after week, Ian Porter’s detailed reflections on each Sunderland match provide superb analysis for subscribes to the Blackcats list, home of some of the most intelligent comment on our club to be found anywhere. In the third part of our end-of-term report series (Pete Sixsmith now reverts, as intended, to the fourth part), Ian* identifies the 1-1 draw at St James’ Park, in a game we ought to have won by half time, as a key turning point in a season that had another tremendous show of guts and consistency from Danny Collins (pictured) but also stuttered – and nearly fell very heavily – after earlier spells of promise …

The season started with a mixture of optimism and pessimism.

(more…)

Who were they then? Winners from the other side

Friday, May 29th, 2009

Wigan wh hires

There’s a lot winning going on: our friends at A Love Supreme have just collected their second successive award for football fanzine of the year, Sunderland “won” the right to stay in the Premier and here – at last – are Salut! Sunderland’s winners in the great Who Are They? awards …

Forget George Orwell, tracing the progress of the same breadcrumb each day on the breakfast table at his lodgings. The Road To Wigan Pier is a marvellous book, but Salut! Sunderland has discovered that the town provides shelter and inspiration for another writer of distinction.

Step forward Bernard Ramsdale, “landlord” of Ye Olde Tree and Crown, the Wigan Athletic fan site and clear winner in our awards for the best contributions to this site by opposing fans during the 2008-09 season.

Bernard, picture below, wins a copy of the customised Wigan Athletic book, kindly donated by Getting Personal. If the excellent Sunderland version of the book is any guide, he will be content with his prize.

(more…)

Fan-tastic day: how to try not to gloat on national TV

Friday, May 29th, 2009

Griff3

Salut! Sunderland was asked, but two thirds of it was going to the match and Setanta couldn’t stump up the fare to get the other third from the south of France to London.
When the offer was relayed to members of the Blackcats list, Stephen Worthy* leapt at the chance and spent Sunday afternoon in the studio with fans of other relegation-haunted teams, including a certain Newcastle United.
Here is a blow-by-blow account from Stephen – aka Griff, a rock, motoring and former SAFC fanzine (
It’s The Hope I Can’t Stand) writer – of a special way of seeing us to safety, Toon safely doon and a Mag safely home …

I’ve made some bad decisions in my time. Like the time I turned down a girl at school for a date; she went on to become a top international model.

But when the Salut! Sunderland editor put out an e-mail last week asking if someone wanted to become the Sunderland representative on a Setanta Sports News fans’ panel for the last weekend of the Premiership season, it sounded like a good gig. At first.

(more…)

Sunderland end of term reports (2): not good enough

Friday, May 29th, 2009

Spice


A slight behind-the-counter hitch has delayed what was intended as the second of Salut! Sunderland's end-of-term reports. We are nearing the end of an extraordinary week (leaving aside minor league football in Rome) for Sunderland, the North East and indeed for this site.

Ellis Short has given us some encouraging clues as to how serious he is about making SAFC a force in football. Colin Randall* – pictured above with Mme Salut at one of the finest Indian restaurants in the world, Sunderland's Spice Bollywood – has perhaps suffered too many false promises and unnecessary relegations to be objective; he nevertheless wishes Ellis well …

Just before someone amazingly close to Salut! Sunderland was kicked out at the end of the third year, the headmaster's comment at the bottom of the report said: "Not good enough for a grammar school."

It didn't need the head at SAFC Grammar to make a similar point at about 4pm on May 24. Every boy and girl in school knew it full well (for the second time this week, no pun intended): we had not shown ourselves to be good enough for the academy known as the Premier League.

Managers are fond of saying the relegated teams are the worst in the league because they finished 18th, 19th and 20th.

We know better. It wouldn't have taken that much of a fluke to produce last day results to send us down. It is not as if improbable combinations have failed to do so in the past (the Jimmy Hill and Wimbledon relegations spring to mind).

Sunderland fans are passionate in their support. They are also capable of steeling themselves to punish the club they love.

Despite the offers on season tickets very smartly announced before our fate was sealed, the punishment for another Championship season would have been severe. Remember how long it took Roy Keane to drive attendances back up even after guiding us from the bottom into a promotion challenge that saw us go up in first place?

Make no mistake. The gates next season would have been dismal, at least until it had become well known that we were not only in contention for an immediate return but hitting goals and scoring victories in a way that brought back memories of the glorious days of the Gray/Johnston left side link ups, the Summerbee crosses and the SuperKev/Quinn goal machine.

And imagine if we'd got to within a whisker of promotion and then failed all the same, with or without a Jeff Whitley-style penalty in a playoff shoot-out.

This has been a dreadful season for Sunderland fans.

As a fan who has lived outside the North East since early adulthood, I have written more than once about having seen, during 18 months in Abu Dhabi, more live Sunderland football than at any time since I was a lad in the main stand paddock or on the Fulwell End at Roker Park.

It was not an especially pleasurable experience. All those games, yes. But also, all those defeats: worse still, all those performances of such incompetence or lack of passion – often enough accompanied by commentary only in Arabic because our games failed to appeal to Rob McCaffrey's Dubai-based studio treatment- that you wanted to kick the television screen.

Ellis Short knows how bad we've been; in his short interview with safc.com he even talked about the lack of fun.

I frankly don't care whether Mrs Ellis Short threw a strop about some people walking their dogs through the grounds of Skibo Castle. Nor will I lie awake wondering what prompted the South Korean authorities to look – though not, in the event, leap if I have correctly understood the archive – into some of his business dealings.

When it comes to Sunderland AFC, all I really care about with regard to Mr Short, Mr Quinn and the rest of them is where they are taking us, and perhaps how. OK, I do care a lot about Mr Quinn because he seems a top bloke and has done more for SAFC than anyone in living memory, but my point otherwise stands.

If where they are taking us is the top 10 finish Ellis Short sees as a good target for next season, that will do me fine for starters.

Drumaville, in my view, put down some decent foundations. The football since promotion has been dire but we've survived.

On the eve of our 5-0 win at Luton to clinch the 2007 Championship title, I said – and wrote, for a national newspaper in Ireland – that fourth bottom 2007/2008 would suffice for lots of long-suffering Sunderland fans. I was one of them, so while it meant an excess of nervewracking moments and on-the-pitch failure – fifth bottom could almost be regarded as a small bonus.

I was not, however, prepared for a repetition this season and will be even less so for 2009-2010.

Ellis, his money and his business acumen are hugely welcome as viewed from my spot, when I can get there, up in the East Stand.

And the words from his Q&A with safc.com that best describe the task in hand are these:

"Our only real goal this year was not to get relegated, and with the money we spent
last summer we probably shouldn't have come as close as we did …
we'll do what we need to do this summer to get this team into a place where we
can try to finish in the top 10 next year. I don't ever want to go through a
relegation battle again and I don't want the fans to have to go through it, I don't
want Niall to have to go through it… And in the longer term we just want to
continue to improve and always run things well. I don't want to promise things and
not be able to deliver but that's genuinely what we are going to try and do."

Do deliver that, Mr Short, and see how grateful we'll all be …

Me at sol* Colin Randall on Colin Randall:

…he has carried the heavy burden of supporting Sunderland since his father took him to a Division Two match at Middlesbrough in which Brian Clough scored the SAFC winner. He is a journalist and, after a spell in France, helped launched a national newspaper in Abu Dhabi (United Arab Emirates) before returning to Europe to divide his time between France and the UK. Perversely, he retains his East Stand season ticket – and is delighted that it is used most games.

The owner speaks: Ellis less Short on words than before

Friday, May 29th, 2009

Another sobering assessment of the season is nearly ready to appear as the second of Salut! Sunderland's end-of-term reports. Meanwhile, amid denials that Drumaville consortium members ended up losing on their investments (everyone received a "respectable" return, according to Niall Quinn, a "modest" one according to them), Ellis Short* has spoken …


Ecstasy
, relief, gratitude to the fans and, in defiance of instructions from Niall Quinn to say how far Sunderland AFC can go, a willingness to stipulate a top 10 finish next season as the first step on that route.

That, in short and in Short's own words, is Ellis, newly elevated to 100 per cent control of the club.

Not the most illuminating, incisive interview you'll ever come across – more Parkinson with favoured guests than Parky with Meg Ryan – but the proper response is probably merci for small mercies. What's more, I've also had to interview my own bosses at times, so know the score …

Read the full interview at the official club site. But it would not infringe copyright rules to offer a couple of his comments.

Short described the emotions he experienced last weekend as being pretty much the same as those of the rest of us.

Happy, yes, but relief was his word of choice, "relief that two months of fear and nervousness is over" and, by implication, the lifting of the threat relegation posed to future development. "We've got a lot of good plans for the future and relegation would have been horrible."

He heaped praise on Niall – a "very smart footballer, very smart about the Premier League and a wonderful chairman who knows more about football than I ever will" – as well as on the supporters.

Sunderland were a "big, proper football club with the best fans in the league" and the benefits of a great stadium, some of football's finest training facilities and enough else to forge a successful, powerful future.

The key answer was to the question on what, a few years from now, could be seen as successful progress.

Ellis Short replied:

"Well Niall told me not to answer that and not to promise too much but … I became involved late last summer and our only real goal this year was not to get relegated, and with the money we spent last summer we probably shouldn't have come as close as we did … we'll do what we need to do this summer to get this team into a place where we can try to finish in the top 10 next year. I don't ever want to go through a relegation battle again and I don't want the fans to have to go through it, I don't want Niall to have to go through it… And in the longer term we just want to continue to improve and always run things well. I don't want to promise things and not be able to deliver but that's genuinely what we are going to try and do."

There's more, as I suggested, so go to the safc.com for the full Q&A.

* A profile in today's Guardian tells of Ellis Short's distaste for the limelight, a spot of unpleasantness with the South Korean authorities and – at odds with not wanting too much attention – his ownership of Skibo Castle, the Scottish wedding venue of Madonna and an exclusive retreat for the monied and powerful.

Extract:
An Irish-American, Short made his fortune in the highly competitive world of private equity and hedge-fund management. He began his career at General Electric before teaming up with business partner John Grayken in the mid-1990s at Lone Star Funds, a private equity firm based in Dallas, Texas, with huge success. It was here Short built up his business acumen, securing his position as senior executive, running the Asian operations. Since 1995, Lone Star have established funds worth more than $13.3bn (